A good story, a clear ask, and a job for everyone

Dear friends, comrades, and colleagues,

It’s so great to be writing to you all after such a massive political shift. I’ve felt lighter since the election, and I’ve felt it in conversations with my clients, too. I’m glad we have real wins to celebrate. There’s a lot to build on, and we’ve still got work to do together.

And here we are, fundraisers. It’s GIVING SEASON. Whether you’re starting from scratch or already have emails queued up, a few small shifts can make a difference. In addition to this newsletter, I put together a new Year-End Fundraising Plan Worksheet to help you figure out where to start or where to build.

Give people one story to follow.

What connects your first email, your social posts, and your last ask in December? Start with something people can picture. My client Mass NOW is raising money to advance menstrual equity. One ask they’re planning for first-time donors is about $25 to cover a month of menstrual products for someone who can’t afford them. When I was at Military Families Speak Out, “Home for the Holidays” tied our organizing and fundraising together. One empty seat at the dinner table told the story. It worked pretty well on politicians’ front lawns, too.

Don’t bury the ask.

If people have to work to figure out what you’re raising money for or what you want them to do, you’ve probably already lost them. I see this all the time in fundraising emails and letters. By the time I get to the donation ask in the last paragraph, I’ve already been asked to RSVP, read a report, and share a post. Put the ask near the top, make it clear what a gift will help to accomplish, and ask again at the end. If you’ve already got the emails and social posts on the calendar and are wondering how to make them feel like one campaign, I wrote more about how to tie them together on LinkedIn.

Give people a job they can say yes to.

Here’s my broken-record moment. You don’t have to hold the whole campaign yourself. Ask a board member to make five thank-you calls, a volunteer who’s been around forever to find a photo with a story behind it, or a supporter to record a quick video about why they give. And if someone’s willing to make an ask but feels weird about it, start with a donor they already know or who has given before. They can tell that person why they’re in and invite them to do something together.

Make it personal.

Once you’ve got a few people willing to help, who should they reach out to, and how? In general, a face-to-face ask goes further than a phone call, a phone call goes further than a personal note, and a personal note goes further than a mass email or social post. People may need to see your campaign in a few places before they give. But if you’ve only got time to call ten people or write one really clever Instagram post, I’d pick up the phone.

Start with people who’ve already shown you they care. Call a few donors who gave last year and haven’t given yet this year. Jot a note on an appeal letter, or forward the campaign email with a sentence about why you thought of them. I once got a “we miss you” email from an organization I’d forgotten I’d previously given to. It felt like they were talking to me, and it got my attention.

My Year-End Fundraising Plan Worksheet digs a little deeper into these questions and gives you a simple checklist for what to do before, during, and after your campaign.

GOOD LUCK - and let’s raise some $!

Nikki

P.S. Got a year-end fundraising question you’d love to talk through? Maybe you’re still figuring out what to ask for, or who to bring in to help. Grab a free call with me and we’ll think it through together.

Next
Next

You don’t have to change who you are to fundraise